I tested the Nintendo Switch 2 for 16 days (here’s why I’m returning it)

As Nintendo gears up for their most ambitious launch yet, I recently had the chance to spend significant hands-on time with the highly anticipated Nintendo Switch 2. With its official release just days away on June 5, 2025, the burning question remains: is this $450 console worth the upgrade? After playing through the launch lineup, I have some thoughts that might surprise you.

First impressions: bigger, faster, but familiar

The moment I picked up the Switch 2, its premium build quality was immediately apparent. The larger 7.9-inch 1080p screen is a significant upgrade from its predecessor, displaying vibrant colors even without the rumored OLED technology. At 0.88 pounds with controllers attached, it maintains surprising portability despite the size increase.

“The Switch 2 has a premium, less toy-like feel, fits adult hands a lot better, and puts the buttons more closely aligned to your fingertips,” notes a representative from Nintendo during my testing session.

Performance that finally delivers on promises

The Switch 2’s custom NVIDIA chip shows impressive muscle. Running Cyberpunk 2077 on a handheld seemed unthinkable just years ago, yet here it runs surprisingly well. The console outputs up to 4K/60fps when docked and maintains 1080p/120fps in handheld mode for supported games.

Load times have been drastically reduced—games that once took 30-45 seconds to launch now spring to life in under 10 seconds. This performance leap feels genuinely next-generation rather than incremental.

The reimagined Joy-Con 2 controllers change the game

The new Joy-Con 2 controllers are substantially larger with improved ergonomics. Their magnetic attachment mechanism is satisfying, while the mouse-like functionality opens up gameplay possibilities previously unavailable on Nintendo platforms.

“The mouse-like capabilities allow for entirely new gameplay mechanics we’re just beginning to explore,” explained a developer working on upcoming strategy titles.

Launch games: impressive but expensive

I tested several launch titles including Mario Kart World, which supports up to 24 players online. The visuals are stunning, showcasing what the hardware can achieve. Enhanced versions of Zelda titles run with flawless frame rates that make the originals seem choppy by comparison.

However, the pricing structure raises eyebrows:

  • New first-party titles cost $70-80
  • Enhanced versions of existing games require $20-30 upgrade purchases
  • No free upgrade path for games you already own

Backward compatibility saves the library

One saving grace is the complete backward compatibility with the original Switch library. Your existing games work seamlessly, though without enhancements unless you purchase upgrade packs.

GameChat and online improvements finally catch up

The new GameChat feature supporting 12-player communication feels long overdue but works exceptionally well. Voice chat integration directly into the system rather than through a phone app represents Nintendo finally modernizing their online approach.

Storage and expansion done right

The jump from 32GB to 256GB internal storage addresses one of the original Switch’s biggest pain points. The microSD Express card slot supporting up to 2TB offers plenty of expansion room.

Is it worth the upgrade?

After my time with the Nintendo Switch 2, I’m left impressed by the hardware but questioning the value proposition. For new Nintendo enthusiasts, the answer is clear—this is the definitive version to buy. For existing Switch owners, the calculation is more complex.

The performance improvements are substantial, but the $450 price tag plus expensive games and upgrade costs create a significant barrier. The Nintendo Switch Gaming Collection you’ve built over years works better on the new hardware, but is that enough?

Nintendo has built a technically impressive device that pushes their unique gaming philosophy forward. Whether it’s worth it ultimately depends on how much you value those improvements—and how deep your gaming budget runs in 2025.